Foreign Aid
11/30/2011
This is how the Slovenian Democratic Party (SDS) addressed Slovene households recently. With a newspaper-like publication entitled “The Smart Solution”. It’s a solid product with content one would expect. Plus a crossword puzzle that could win you a prize as nice as a TV set or an iPad. This is not what drew my attention.
The very top of the first page features statements of support from Angela Merkel and Jyrki Katainen. As I walked past the booths set up by political parties in down-town Ljubljana today, the one draped in yellow by SDS included a TV screen from which foreign politicians were expressing their support to the party or rather to its leader Janez Janša. The party boasts foreign or – as they term it – international support on both its Slovene website and the rather impressively extensive English site.
The first time I heard of Angela Merkel’s support for Janez Janša and saw the video, I thought it was a nice gesture in support of a member of the same European political group, but nothing really substantive. The German chancellor has offered support to colleagues before that she must have regretted, namely Ivo Sanader. Interestingly, his Wikipedia page includes a photo of him with both people on whose support SDS puts so much stress. But how could she have known that he would prove an embarrassment? In any case, this is beside the point unless the point is to show that Angela Merkel’s support for a politician does not necessarily mean said politician is the right choice.
My thoughts are elsewhere. Why would or why should Slovene voters care whether foreign politicians support a candidate or a party in a national election? As I voiced my reservation on Twitter, the response offered was that it was very important for Slovenia to have good relations with Germany. This is true, of course, but I do not remember Slovenia having anything but excellent relations with the great European economy. If I start the count after WWII, naturally.
The Hungarian head of state also expressed his support for SDS. Hungary. Seriously? Note its present condition. Yes, Viktor Orban, the autocrat, supports SDS. Of course it is logical that parties under the umbrella of the European People’s Party support each other and on the one hand, I most probably naively think it is a good sign that within the European Union, political ties based on agendas and not nationality are growing stronger. On the other hand, I think it ill to rely on an assessment of a politician who watches from a distance and has most probably not spent much of her time studying your country, much less lived in it or intends to do so.
It is my contention that foreign politicians meddling with national politics would be bad news. I am not, however, saying that this is the case with Merkel et al. I sincerely doubt that any of these national politicianswould ask Slovene voters outright to cast a vote for a specific politician or party. What they understand and what Slovene voters should understand is that they are bound by their national interests. They were elected to do what is best for their respective countries. Not ours.
Seeing foreigners advise Slovenes who to vote for leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Are we really so insecure and convinced of our own irrelevance that we feel worthy only when patted on the back from abroad? Can you imagine the leading party (per polls) in any other country setting up a booth to run videos of foreign politicians supporting them? Colour me annoyed.
brane said,
November 30, 2011 @ 7:20 am
hja, takle mamo …
Bimbo said,
November 30, 2011 @ 10:07 am
Very bad taste indeed. Exactly as you stated, I can’t imagine how Germans would have accepted, if G.Bush told them to vote for his good friend A. Merkel. Etc.
Anyway, it’s worth having a quick look at the SDS’ website, the part with selected, hand-picked articles: http://www.sds.si/arhiv?id=22&year=2011&month=11#2011_11.
One immediately notices several citations of a certain provocative author of Finance newspaper. Several, almost all recent, but the very one which is titled Let us reset Janez Janša: http://www.finance.si/328451/Public-enemy-Resetirajmo-Janeza-Jan%C5%A1o.
Finally, my question is, which Slovene political party (or its leader) has personal support from Messrs. Obama, Putin, Medvedev and Hu Jintao? 😈
Iaxa said,
November 30, 2011 @ 11:03 am
The intra-EPP cross-support is actually a harmless mean to convince the convinced. A tricky and probably efficient approach is the advertising through this editorial (http://www.partis.si/clanek/8705) on Slovenia’s most popular P2P website, addressing mostly young people to support SDS as “the only party which would protect P2P sharing (internet piracy)”. It may actually reap some undecided naive youngsters.
dr.filomena said,
December 1, 2011 @ 8:27 am
@Brane: pa tkole se dajemo …
@Bimbo: Oh, an interesting link up there, thanks. Just read today’s piece by the well-regarded public enemy and expect a link to appear in that archive soon, next to the others. And a jewel awaits at the second link. Thanks for bringing it to attention again 😉
@Iaxa: The EPP cross-support indeed is harmless. What bothers me is that such support can become the cornerstone of a political campaign. The number one asset of a political party. Ok, in addition to the printed booklet that contains one of and not the best of the party programmes.
As for Partis, thanks for this, I was unaware of it. I did, however, notice huge discrepancies in SDS statements on the issue of piracy ranging anywhere from one must not prosecute piracy to not prosecuting it leads to economic damage to the holders of intellectual property rights. Not much consistency there, but when it comes to this party, what else is new.
Adriaan said,
December 2, 2011 @ 1:11 pm
Firstly let me commend you (again) for a very well written and thought provoking article.
The concept of foreign leaders endorsing home certain politicians or parties in other countries is certainly disturbing. The U.K. government has, I believe, an unspoken policy of not doing such a thing close to important elections which personally I think is the correct course of action.
Certainly, even in the European Union, national instincts and preferences will always override the greater good; At least they do at the moment.
The U.K. has been a victim of this sort of thing too, in the past. In previous elections we’ve had Eurocrats voicing opinions of whom they’d prefer to see re-elected (which probably, given their reputation and the U.K. electorates awkwardness, had the opposite effect!).
That said being said, of course it’s very easy for the politician in question to either take such comments out of context or without regard to when it was actually said. I think the blame can be equally shared.
It’s certainly a distasteful and disturbing trend.
Dr. ARF said,
December 2, 2011 @ 1:12 pm
What I take from this is that foreign politicians endorsing a certain party is a double edged sword. On the one hand it is used to prove said party’s validity and trustworthiness – something SDS in the persona of good ol’ JJ has been firmly lacking – within the EU. Basically they’re saying : “Look! Big Boss Merkel likes us! If she trusts us, so should you!” On the other hand : it is a sign of weakness. I mean, really : is SDS so insecure that they would need the endorsement of politicians outside of Slovenija to shore up their voting percentages? A point you also aptly made in your post.
Another issue SDS seems to forget, is that by now, the economic crisis is also starting to hit Germany. German state bonds are now also depreciating in value, so banking on Merkel as a ‘strong economic ally’ within the EU framework could be dangerous in the long term (I’m totally disregarding Orban, who probably only is being used as the representative of the ‘friendly neighbour state (as well as former ‘partner’ in the Austro- Hungarian Empire, do not underestimate that piece of common political history’) but represents no strong european political or economical force, unlike Deutschland, since Hungary, last I heard, is also in economic turmoil and has been for longer than even Greece, a fact that seems lost on most of the EU economist media).
What it all comes down to in the end, is that this is just another poltical propaganda tool. My guess is that SDS’s communication advisors – an ever increasing interest group within the political party framework – took a leaf out of the roadbook of American politics. I don’t have to remind anyone that president Obama basically went on a world tour to shore up support for his election and was seen with various political leaders who seemingly endorsed him. It was an international publicity campaign, geared toward a national audience of voters. Now, of course SDS can’t go to the U.S. and ask the Big O to endorse them, so they’re doing it Slovenian style : shore up support in the neighbouring countries (they can’t go to Croatia, since there still are several political issues between the former YU countries) and what seems to be the biggest economical force in the EU. As luck would have it, these are all grouped under the EPP flag.
In that sense, they could just as well have asked President Van Rompuy for good measure, since his national party, the CD&V, also flies under the EPP banner within European politics. So does Berlusconi, for that matter, but I’m guessing his support would send out the wrong message now that SDS is trying to clean up their act. But the bottom line is still that this is all smoke and mirrors and ‘panem et circenses’, if you will, as political campains usually are. Policy is not made by outside forces, it is made within. And soon enough all the sins of the past SDS is trying to gloss over with this shiny EU- tinseled campaign will come to the surface again. In my book, it is not a sign of strength, it is a sign of weakness, but if I read Mr. P.’s projections right, it won’t stand in the way of SDS winning next Sunday…
Slovenia: Dec. 4 Elections Updates · Global Voices said,
December 2, 2011 @ 11:01 pm
[…] on the upcoming Dec. 4 parliamentary elections – by Dr. Filomena and Sleeping With Pengovsky (here, here, here, and here). Pengovsky concludes: “The way it […]
Slovenian Elections: The Janković Upset | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY said,
December 5, 2011 @ 3:10 pm
[…] of calmness and composure. Janša was already meeting with labour unions, EU ambassadors and was receiving support from fellow right-wing party leaders throughout Europe (including ill-concieved support from the jailed Julia Timošenko of Ukraine and […]